At this early stage, it's perhaps a good idea to point out that I've only ever seen one episode of The X-Factor. However, in my defence, it was from this series, so suck it up. I remember a number of acts from that solitary, drunken episode, during which I was carving a pumpkin to look like Adolf Hitler. The one I remember most was Diana Vickers, who had the most interesting voice and style of all of the amorphous blobs on parade. And also because she sung Man In The Mirror, a song with a key change which is the stuff of legend.I also have a faint recollection of a boy band who look like a front for a crime syndicate - one of them sings, acting as a distraction as the other three rob you - but who apparently made it all the way to the final. There was also a woman who always sang in Spanish, seemingly by way of some bizarre psychological tic, a woman old enough to be everyone else's mother and who may well have been inside and, another finallist, Eoghan Quinn, who has a face looks like it has been drawn by a child on a paper plate. He is also in possession of one of those Gaelic names which Irish people like to give their children to mess the English up, so I will hereby refer to him as Wogan. However, they were not, on the whole, a distinguished bunch.
No surprise, then, that someone who had left an indelible blank on me emerged as the winner. Alexandra Burke is, apparently, 20 years old and from North London. Alexandra Burke. Alexandra Burke. Alexandra Burke.
Now I have remembered that her name is Alexandra Burke (or something), we can reflect on what it means. In the short term, it means she'll almost certainly have the Christmas number 1 single, which younger readers may not realise was once a big deal before the days of Pop Idol-style programmes filling the festive charts with Beauticians, Binmen and Assistant managers from River Island. In the long term, who knows? Looking back at the winners of these shows, it's pretty much 50-50 as to whether she (her name is Alexandra Burke, remember) will carve out a career as successful as any of her vanquished peers. Because although The X-Factor and the pop charts are popularity contests, the one thing neither can control is time or talent. I think Diana Vickers will most likely make a significant impact in the short to mid-term. Indeed, I hope she does. She's easily the most interesting talent I saw on display, plus The Daily Mail seem to hate her. What's not to like?
The boy band, whose name is JLS and who came in second place, will probably sink without a trace, but who knows? There's not been a really big boy band to get all the girls' knees knocking for a worryingly long time. Meanwhile, Wogan, who the tabloid press will have you believe has already porked Diana Vickers and, as such, already has celebrity form, will probably hang around like the sort of fart you do and then leave the room with it still in tow.
I'm not against these talent shows. Some of the people that have emerged from them - Girls Aloud and Will Young particularly - have really gone on to produce. However, in Will Young's case, it's doubtful that someone with his talent would have continued to reside within anonymity. Girls Aloud really needed to be put together - the majority of girl groups and boy bands being as organic as their manager's wife's breasts - and that's another area in which these talent shows have something to offer. People have been putting pop acts like this together behind closed doors for years. What Pop Idol, Popstars and all the rest have done is turn it into a socio-anthropological exercise. Notebooks at the ready.
However, what sociological investigations can't ever guarantee is entertainment. Because, mostly, the contestants are planks. Even the better ones, the ones who reach the latter stages - which can't even be guaranteed since the idiot general public are doing the hiring and firing - are pretty much indistinguishable from each other. Occasionally, as in life and as they would be behind closed doors, someone brilliant will come along or be unearthed. But, considering the likelihood of fallow years to follow, could someone not just film the whole thing and let us know later? Because currently, The X-Factor is as boring as watching the Lotto draw, but much, much longer.



